A recent court decision highlights Housing Development Fund Corporation (also known as "HDFC") tenants' rights with respect to eviction proceedings, and the greater protections those tenants have.
In 823 East 147th Street Housing Development Fund Corp. v. Hinnant (NYLJ 1202649981134, at 1, Civil Court, Bronx, decided March
28, 2014), the petitioner landlord, a non-profit Housing Development Fund Cooperative Corporation,
commenced a holdover eviction proceeding at the expiration of the tenant's lease,
but without service of a predicate termination notice. Before serving an answer, the tenant moved pursuant to CPLR 3211(a) to dismiss the proceeding
asserting that the petition failed to state a cause
of action upon which relief could be granted (including that it failed to provide a reason for the eviction), and the petitioner opposed and argued that it was not required to allege a
reason for the termination because the tenant did not take possession of
the subject apartment until after the HDFC conversion.
Ultimately, the Bronx Civil Court dismissed the petitioner's action, citing the lack of any reason for the eviction (other than the expiration of the tenancy), and that HDFC tenants are entitled to greater protections by way of the U.S. Constitution as HDFC facilities are "entwined" with the government, as displayed as follows: "[i]t is well established that where a governmental entity meaningfully
participates in the operation or control of a building so as to be
significantly 'entwined' with it, eviction proceedings must comply with
constitutional Procedural Due Process guarantees...[w]ith respect to HDFCs, a government agency fixes their rentals,
requires the availability of units to occupants within certain income
guidelines, and restricts the use of any their profits...thereby triggering Due Process
protections. Among the most basic of these protections is notice to the
tenant of the cause for the eviction, other than mere expiration of the
tenancy...."
Salvatore R. Marino, Esq.
I'm here to share my testimony of what a good trusted loan company did for me. My name is Nikita Tanya, from Russian and I’m a lovely mother of 3 kids I lost my funds on trying to get a loan it was so hard for me and my children, I went online to seek for a loan assistance all hope was lost until one faithful day when I met this friend of mine who recently secured a loan from a very honest man Mr, Benjamin. She introduced me to this honest loan officer Mr, Benjamin who helped me get a loan in within 5 working days, I will forever be grateful to Mr Benjamin, for helping me get back on feet again. You can contact Mr Benjamin via email: 247officedept@gmail.com they do not know I’m doing this for them, but i just have to do it because a lot of people are out there who are in need of a loan assistance please come to this honest man and you can be save as well .WhatsApp:(+1 989-394-3740)
ReplyDelete